Oklahoma is synonymous with unpredictable weather. When the sirens wail, every second counts. Choosing between a garage storm shelter and a backyard storm shelter is one of the most important safety decisions a homeowner can make. Both offer life-saving protection, but they cater to different property types and family needs.
This guide explores the differences, benefits, and considerations for each to help you determine which fit is best for your Oklahoma home.
Garage Storm Shelters: Convenience Meets Speed
For many Oklahomans, the garage is the most logical place for a storm shelter. These units are typically installed directly into the concrete floor of your garage, flush with the surface so you can still park your vehicle over them.
1. Instant Accessibility
The primary advantage of a garage shelter is speed. When a tornado warning is issued, you don’t have to face the elements. You simply walk into your garage and step inside. This is especially beneficial during nighttime storms or high-wind events where flying debris makes being outdoors dangerous.
2. Space-Saving Design
Because these shelters are installed beneath the floor, they do not take up any additional “real estate” on your property. You maintain your full yard space and your garage remains functional for storage and parking.
3. Protection from the Elements
In Oklahoma, tornadoes are often accompanied by torrential rain, hail, and extreme winds. A garage shelter allows you to stay dry and safe from falling hail while transitioning into your secure space.
4. Discreet Safety
If you prefer to keep your safety measures private or want to maintain your home’s curb appeal, garage shelters are invisible from the street. They do not alter the landscape of your front or backyard.
Backyard Storm Shelters: Space and Flexibility
If your garage is cluttered, or if you have a large family, a backyard shelter might be the superior choice. These are often “slope” style or “flat-top” underground bunkers installed in an open area of your property.
1. Increased Capacity
Backyard shelters generally offer more internal square footage than standard garage units. If you have a large family, frequent guests, or multiple large pets, a backyard unit provides the breathing room necessary to remain comfortable during long periods of sheltering.
2. Superior Ventilation
Outdoor shelters often have more flexibility regarding ventilation pipe placement. This can lead to better airflow, which is a critical factor when multiple people are confined in a small space for an extended duration.
3. Ease of Installation
Installing a shelter in an existing garage requires cutting through concrete and excavating in a confined space. If your garage has post-tension cables or limited clearance, a backyard installation is often faster and less invasive to the home’s structure.
4. Accessibility for Pets
Leading a large dog down a narrow garage ladder can be difficult. Many backyard shelters feature wider stairs or sloped entries that make it much easier to bring pets inside quickly.
Key Comparison: At a Glance
Factors to Consider Before You Install
Property Layout and Soil
Oklahoma soil varies from red clay to rocky terrain. An expert installer from Oklahoma Shelters will evaluate your property to ensure the ground is suitable for excavation. In some cases, high water tables may influence whether an underground or above-ground unit is safer.
Family Mobility
Consider the physical needs of your household. If you have family members with mobility issues, you may want to look into Above-Ground Safe Rooms. However, between the two underground options, ensure the stairs and entryways are manageable for everyone in the home.
Vehicle Clearance
If you choose a garage shelter, you must ensure your vehicle has enough clearance to be moved or parked in a way that doesn’t block the shelter door. Modern garage shelters are designed so that most cars can park directly over them, but the sliding door must remain accessible.
Why Professional Installation Matters
Regardless of the type you choose, the effectiveness of a storm shelter relies entirely on its construction and installation. Oklahoma’s weather can produce incredible pressure changes and debris impact.
-
FEMA Compliance: Ensure your shelter meets or exceeds FEMA P-320 and ICC-500 standards.
-
Registered with the City: Professional installers help ensure your shelter is registered so emergency responders know where to look for you after a storm.
-
Proper Anchoring: A backyard shelter must be properly weighted and anchored to prevent “floating” during heavy rains and high water tables.
Which One Is Right for You?
The decision ultimately comes down to your lifestyle and your property’s constraints.
Choose a Garage Shelter if:
-
You want the fastest possible access.
-
You want to stay dry during the storm.
-
You want to keep your backyard clear for gardening or play.
Choose a Backyard Shelter if:
-
You have a large family or many pets.
-
Your garage is too small for an installation.
-
You prefer a unit with more interior headspace and ventilation.
Your Safety, Your Choice
At Oklahoma Shelters, we specialize in protecting what matters most. Whether you prefer the convenience of the garage or the space of the backyard, we provide expert installation and top-tier protection. Don’t wait until the next storm clouds gather on the horizon.
